Skip to main content

Open Note Essay Thanksgiving (Annotated)

Joshua Eastin
Block D
11/28/2018
Open-Note Research Article


Depiction of 'First Thanksgiving'



Similar to the legend of the American Cowboy the fantasy of the first Thanksgiving, often mistaken as
fact, is far from the truth. The myth persisted through modern day due to a combination of cultural
tradition,political agenda, and corporate influence. There are aspect of the legend which are true; there was a
harvest celebration in Plymouth in the 1620’s in which indians from the Wampanoag tribe attended, and it
is possible, although unlikely, that turkey was served during the feast. However, this is where the truth
deviates from the common story. While there was a celebration the reason for it was not to give thanks,
instead it was to celebrate a successful harvest. The New York Times says that this kind of festival
wasn’t unique and was a common occurrence. The Wampanoag tribe were likely just neighbors who
joined the gathering and weren’t formally invited. The pilgrims at the time were just enjoying a
common celebration, unaware of how this event would be viewed in the future.


The Thanksgiving day celebration has its roots as far back as the late 1700’s when the some of
the founding fathers attempted to make the already popular holiday into a national holiday. It was
not allowed primarily due to Jefferson objecting because of the religions connotations of the
holiday in what was to be a secular government. This shows that people were celebrating
Thanksgiving long before it was recognized as a national holiday. Although at this time the
holiday wasn’t associated with the Plymouth festival and it had different traditions depending on
where it was being celebrated. Some of the local traditions of Thanksgiving found their way
into other modern holidays. Local culture eventually brought the story of the ‘First Thanksgiving’
in the public when in 1830 New Englanders believed it resembled their thanksgiving traditions.

Finally how Thanksgiving became a national holiday can be attributed to the Civil War. In a time
where the nation was devastated and divided Abraham Lincoln enacted the holiday for unity and
thankfulness. Unity because of how people of both North and South could celebrate the new
holiday. Thankfulness to thank the veterans of the Civil War in the famous battles of the war.
In Fact the early years of the holiday likely resembled veterans day with a focus on military
thanks and thanks to a nation rather than thanks to friends and family. As the years progressed
into the 1900’s the holiday began to take shape transitioning into the holiday we are all familiar
with.

The thanksgiving holiday has been through several changes since it was celebrated centuries ago. From
'
a simple harvest festival in the 1600’s to a local holiday to a national day of thanks. Through the first Thanksgiving changed into the holiday known today. national and local culture, and political influence of important events in history the common story of the


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Semester II Final

Part A: 1. Before doing any research, I predict the three most highly ranked presidents in US history will be: President Abraham Lincoln provided a way to create unity in the United States while progressing the moral values of the country. George Washington would likely be near the top of that list due to the work he put forward in creating the nation. Jefferson would also be considered a successful president after making the Louisiana perchance which vastly expanded US territory. and the worst might be, when evaluating by public opinion, are the most recent presidents due to the increasingly dividing political climate. Nixon is also remembered as one of the worst presidents due to his involvement in Water Gate. 2. According the the C-Span Survey  the presidents who are consistently in the top 4 are: Abraham Lincoln, George Washington, Franklin D. Roosevelt, and Theodore Roosevelt. While there were no two presidents who went back a forth in the 4th and 5th slots as Theodore Roos

Economic Impact from Immigration

A common argument that is used both in favor and against immigration is the economic impact of immigration. Through research I have found that while it is near impossible to definitively state whether immigrants in large quantities are helpful or harmful the united states economy, their effect in either direction does not have a substantial impact in most aspects of the economy. While there are significant differences in first generation immigrants and native residents their overall impact does not have significant effect on the average American. Arguably the most important is on population. Immigration in recent years has reached levels of the early 1900's except now most immigrants are from Asia and Latin america instead of Europe. According a US census survey, growth in american prime working age individuals is mostly contributed by immigrants having a ~ 2% growth in prime age immigrants with native citizens losing prime age population at ~ -0.5% growth. I was unable to find s

Open Note Essay Ripple Effect (Annotated)

Joshua Eastin Block D 12/13/2018 Radio Ripple effect The radio give one of history's best and most influential examples of technology changing how people interact with their society. As radio evolved from a military device to a common amenity it also evolved american culture giving america the strongest national identity of the early 20th century. This unprecedented advancement was accomplished through the radio’s ability to give marketers access to a new form mass market giving exposure which newspaper could never achieve. Corporations were not the only ones to take advantage of this new medium, politicians and musicians also became common on the radio. This lead america into a national identity which would be a primary cause of the Americana culture of the early 1950’s. The invention of radio is usually stated in the range of 1890’s to early 1900’s but its invention can be traced back as far as the 1850’s when experimentation of low frequency waves began. However, this ra